The crosstrek isnt a particularly sporty vehicle to begin with, so im not sure how much a cvt vs manual is going to matter in the funtodrive department. Still thinking about getting a manual crosstrek, but the gas mileage is a bit better for cvt. The 2015 subaru wrx is one of this years standout new performance cars. Mar 18, 2014 the manual has worse fuel economy than the cvt. Drones, boatload to fix, there have been a fair number of failures as well. Now, youve heard from editor bober, who has deemed the cvttoting subaru wrx superior to the manual version, and from me who has firmly stated the exact opposite. Cvt vs automatic transmissions cvt pros and cons cj. A regular transmission can feel jerky, especially under full throttle.
The best way to answer your question is to test drive one with the 5spd and decide which one you like better, its all a matter of personal preference. I come from a 2010 subaru wrx so i have mostly driven manual transmission. A more real world test of acceleration is the rolling 560 mph. With this type of transmission, your car is always in the right gear. Mar 28, 2018 when you are choosing a car to buy an important thing to consider is what type of transmission you want. This means that you can take advantage of the impressive efficiency that cvt offers when you want tobut when you feel the need to take things into your own hands with manual transmission, you can do so freely. I love driving and for me, the pleasure of been on the road and enjoying the car is important. All the same, these engine and cvt box combinations didnt deliver much acceleration, a manual box would likely do and be better. Subaru offers a 6speed manual gearbox and a new sport lineartronic cvt in the 2018 wrx. This is likely due to the short 6th gear on the 6speed manual. Though continually variable transmissions cvts dont require a driver to manually change gears, theyre still very different from traditional automatic transmissions.
A cvt draws top engine power from a small engine, which gives drivers quicker acceleration than standard automatic transmissions. Crosstrek manual vs cvt subaru xv crosstrek forums. Subaru manufactures its own manual and cvt transmissions for non kei cars. Cvt equipped impreza sedan and hatchback models gets an epaestimated 28 mpg in the city and 36 mpg on the highway, which are excellent numbers for the compact car class, especially for an allwheeldrive model. A key benefit of the cvt is its ability to change its gear ratio continuously as the engine speed changes. Unlike an automatic or even a manual unit, the cvt is programmed to keep the engines speed square. Check out all the vital info sidebyside from pricing to performance specs. The world of automotive engineering is one of trends and crafting things that will work to overcome the natural limitations of a world bound to a stringent list of physics. Subaru gives 2019 crosstrek a few tweaks and a price bump.
Model year 2018 and newer crosstrek manual vs cvt subaru. In manual mode i leave the transmision change gears on its own beacause its not redlineable. Adding an automatic, i figured, reduced the appeal of the wrx. Owning a cvt instead of a manual might be a good reason to consider an extended warranty, especially if your civic also comes with variable timing hondas vtec.
For years, it only came with a manual in canada meaning that only hardcore driving buffs of the highest order could drive one. A manual cvt is both the best and worst automotive idea ever. Fa dit hi i know there is another thread on dyno difference its a bit inconclusive but i would like to ask people who have driven both, as to whether cvt is noticably less thrusty than 6sp manual when accelerating at wot. Learn about the four most popular transmissions by product expert posted in auto school on monday, august 12th, 2019 at 8. Subaru offers a 6speed manual gearbox and a new sport lineartronic cvt in. Cvtequipped impreza sedan and hatchback models gets an epaestimated 28 mpg in the city and 36 mpg on the highway, which are excellent numbers for the compact car class, especially for an allwheeldrive model. Subaru outback cvt general discussion car talk community. The metal was a nice touch because not only is it generally stronger, but its also believed to reduce the annoying noise associated with cvts called cvt whine subaru engineers made the bold claim that the cvt was maintenance free as pointed out in this 2009 article on the car connection. Before i say anything else, one thing right off the bat is that a manual transmission will likely have much less operating expenses over 1020 years then the cvt.
Ive been digging through the subreddit to see how people felt about the manual vs cvt and have read that the manual tends to be sluggish and not really worth it. Understanding how cvts operate, as well as their pros and cons, can help drivers decide if a cvt equipped vehicle is right for them. Pros and cons of continuously variable transmissions carfax. Car and driver tested both a cvt and manual in 2015, and for that the manual did it in 6. Manual vs automatic offroad manual vs automatic offroad, which is better for offroad.
The cvt is sluggish, but the manual transmission shifts smoothly. I dont care about off the line acceleration because i dont need it. In 6speed manual mode, paddle shifters are mounted for fingertip control, giving you the power. Subarus lineartronic cvt vs 6speed manual in the wrx. Sep 18, 2017 im trying to understand why the 18 crosstrek equipped with a cvt gets 3mpg more than the same model equipped with a manual transmission. I do have one issue with this cvt and that is the use of fake gears, so we can pretend we have a normal automatic i guess. Does the crosstrek cvt have the paddle shifters, and if so, does anyone use. Subaru design subaru of america official subaru site. The cvt builds power in a smooth, linear manner, hence the trademark, lineartronic.
Im getting ready to place an order for the 2018 crosstrek but am having a hard time deciding whether i want to get the manual or cvt version. They prefer to invest their idle time to talk or hang out. And if youre considering putting one of these affordable allwheeldrive sport sedans in your driveway, you have a fundamental choice to make. Nov 29, 2017 once the cvt started to fall out of its standard warranty, owners were met with increased hesitations, jarring shudders, and even the occasional stalls. I thought it was natural variability in driving patterns with a manual transmission. Do you go with the sixspeed manual, or the socalled lineartronic continuously variable automatic transmission cvt. Subarus cvt is one of the best weve driven, and perhaps the best weve experienced in a performanceoriented car.
I own a 21010 subaru outback with the cvt transmission. Subarus cvt is one of the best weve driven, and perhaps the best weve experienced. Firstgeneration cvts were pretty awful to drive and im looking at you, firstgeneration honda hrv. Though there are no gears in a cvt, some allow manual shifting. This means the engine is always operating at its peak efficiency. This video is for those that are not sure if they should buy a manual or. Dont look for subaru to drop the cvt automatic transmission. Just wanted to give you some other stuff to think about. The cvt is a very good, well designed transmission. I would highly recommend the cvt unless you prefer driving a stick. Subaru motor vehicles have used manual, conventional automatic, and continuously variable cvt transmissions. This is a subaru forum comparing cvt vs manual xmission. However, recently a third option has come onto the market cvt, which stands for continuously variable transmission.
Well, i cant speak to the 2010 outback auto cvt but i can give my experience thus far with the 6speed manual. Enough complaints were made that subaru eventually agreed to extend the cvt warranty for 1. This is accomplished either by moving the shift lever or clicking on steering wheelmounted paddles. But i find manual shifting to be more interesting driving. Subaru lineartronic continuously variable transmission cvt. The notable exception is a continuously variable transmission cvt, which is also known as a gearbox. Im new on this forum and new in subaru im planing to change my current toyota tacoma for a new wrx, but i really dont know witch one will be better for me i have two options.
And in that test the cvt and manual are lot closer. May 12, 2014 the 2015 subaru wrx is one of this years standout new performance cars. The only cvt i found that could deliver the sporting performance i wanted with the easy drive of an auto was the xts lineartronic. With the cvt, the 2020 subaru crosstrek comes loaded with standard active safety features. Honda manual vs cvt general discussion car talk community. Traditionally the choice was between an automatic transmission and a manual transmission. Hi my name is paul and i live in ontario canada and im not that well with driving stick and thinking about getting a wrx, but would a cvt be good as i heard their are lots of problems with them. Our main reason for chosing cvt is the mpg it offers. Subaru wrx questions what is better a cvt or manual wrx. Jan 05, 2020 pros of cvt vs automatic transmission. Nov 21, 2017 the manual gearbox also is restricted to the crosstreks two lower trim levels2. However their cvts performed better on our hills than the other makes.
The honda crv and subaru crosstrek are examples of models equipped with a cvt transmission. Both lineartronic cvt and many subaru automatic transmission choices come with manual shift mode. The lineartronic design uses two hydraulically operated pulleys connected by a metal chain. When in d drive and i downshift using the paddles, for example from 6 to 4,the transmission stays in that gear even when you accelerate or decelerate, for 30 35 seconds, this can be a problem when trying to merge into traffic since the transmision should downshift to 3 or 2 when you step on it. In automatic mode, the lineartronic cvt adjusts instantly to match your acceleration, eliminating the need to shift and preserving the vehicles momentum often lost with conventional automatic transmissions. I really dont think driving the mt in a wrx will ever be a chore for me, always brings a smile to my face. Here, the beltandpulley system moves to preset points that simulate changing gears. But i have to admit, the eyesight technology looks really cool so that is one advantage the cvt has. My wife and i have been driving manual xmissions for well over million miles. Perhaps this is to be able to market the cvt as the more fuel efficient choice, perhaps not. Nov 27, 2019 though there are no gears in a cvt, some allow manual shifting. Jun 23, 2019 because there are no gears in a cvt, it allows for manual shifting.
Maybe you will like hondas cvt as well as i liked subarus cvtor maybe notbut only you can decide. I do all city driving and will be going with a cvt 23 mpg manual vs 27 cvt. Its smooth and provides good acceleration for passing, entering the freeway, etc. How does the kia seltos compare to the subaru crosstrek. When you are choosing a car to buy an important thing to consider is what type of transmission you want. The beltandpulley system moves to preset points that simulate changing gears. Since the 1970s, all subaru conventional automatic transmissions have been jatco designs adapted to subaru specifications. Subaru made a perfect market for the cvt by fitting an absolutely abysmal manual transmission to the engine. Lineartronic continuously variable transmission subaru. Because there are no gears in a cvt, it allows for manual shifting. Cvt vs automatic transmissions cvt pros and cons cj pony. Im trying to understand why the 18 crosstrek equipped with a cvt gets 3mpg more than the same model equipped with a manual transmission.
Digital trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on. If youre towing, or you just want the thrill of changing gears, subaru gives. The manual gearbox also is restricted to the crosstreks two lower trim levels2. At least that vehicle was hateful across the board, and.
1617 704 1439 574 65 1578 598 1413 647 1463 663 1570 292 1599 363 28 545 1435 1606 682 1609 1039 483 942 101 232 1038 218 800 1345 848 509